Movie Shark Header

movie shark deblore
Film Critic to the Culver City Observer and over 129 Publications Worldwide including: The Observer, Inc., John Schimmenti, Inc., CCN, Inc., Santa Monica Observer, Inc., Beacon-Times, Inc., Columbus-Register, Inc., and a Host of Others

[Home]
[This Weeks Reviews]
[Recent Reviews]
[Review Archive]
[A]
[B]
[C]
[D]
[E]
[F]
[G]
[H]
[I]
[J]
[K]
[L]
[M]
[N]
[O]
[P]
[Q]
[R]
[S]
[T]
[U]
[V]
[W]
[X]
[Y]
[Z]
[Top Ten]
[Oscars]
[Film Festivals]
[Coming Soon]
[Studio Links]
[Other Links]
[Contact movie shark deblore]
[Straight To DVD]
[Trailers]
[Photo Galleries]
[Golden Globe Awards]
[Legal]

Birth

by

debbie lynn elias

It's been ten years since Anna's husband dropped dead on the pavement while jogging. And although Sean's memory will always live on in her heart, she is ready to move on with her life. In fact, she's found a new love with Joseph and is ready to settle down and remarry. At her posh Fifth Avenue engagement party, Anna and her guests get the shock of their lives when a young 10 year old boy suddenly and mysteriously appears at the party as dimmed lights are raised and candles extinguished. Somber and morose, with a deep voice that echos of malevolence, the child announces that he is Sean, Anna's dead husband. More than taken aback, Anna and her family think this a cruel joke. Despite this, Anna is drawn to the boy, even mesmerized, as he regales events, instances, conversations, that only Sean would know. Even more convincing is a hidden passion in the boy that Anna has felt before - with her dead husband Sean.

Danny Huston and Nicole Kidman in New Line Cinema's Birth
Photo © Copyright New Line Cinema

Nicole Kidman turns in an emotionally charged and fulfilling performance with her portrayal of Anna. With this role, above all others, she allows you to see inside the character, making the audience one with Anna as she transitions and transforms with a mere look. Impassioned and sentient, Kidman gives inner vision to Anna, as the character unfolds and embraces the seemingly impossible concept of reincarnation resulting in a powerful expressiveness that defies description.

Recently seen earlier this year in "Godsend" a similarly chilling work dealing with cloning and the essence of reincarnation, Cameron Bright as young Sean is spellbinding. With a maturity of a man three times his age, Bright has an unnatural ease with the adult tones, dialogue and mannerisms of his character, all of which aid in giving voice to the dead husband and adding new dimensions to this already multi-tiered work. His chemistry with Kidman actually evokes a sense of tragic romanticism, not to mention a believability in the theories of reincarnation. I fully expect to see an Oscar nomination as Best Supporting Oscar for Bright come January given this performance.

Lauren Bacall as Anna's upper crust, prim and proper mother Eleanor, provides a much needed grounding and counter balance to the "surreal." And as comes as no surprise, she is as always, impeccably perfect. Anne Heche also turns in a winning work with her portrayal of Clara, a woman with her own mysterious ties to Sean.

Written by the team of Milo Addica, Jean-Claude Carriere and director Jonathan Glazer, "Birth" borders on the lubricious and licentious with its not too subtle sexual undertones in the relationship between Anna and Sean, while constantly pushing the envelope on the reincarnative premise in an interestingly provocative manner. Solely due to Kidman's meticulously calculated performance, does the relationship not go from chaste and inexplicable to mysterious to salacious smut. Perhaps the most impactful moment of the film arises from an eloquently, albeit chilling monologue, delivered by Kidman. And while her delivery is key, it is the words themselves that will linger long after the film's end. A shortcoming in the script, however, is a true lack of development in the history of Anna and adult Sean and the depth of their love and her loss which results in a void as to an explanation for the intensity of the Anna and young Sean relationship.

Directed by Glazer, this is an imposingly ominous, yet impeccable, work. From patterned pacing to the lush contrast-filled cinematography of Harris Savides, "Birth" is a visually and emotionally impressive work. Adding a profoundness to the overall essence of the film is the piano-heavy score by Alexandre Desplat.

Sadly, the excellence of the film is dampened by its ending as Glazer fails to tie up the many loose threads that have been set loose throughout the first 75 minutes, giving rise to even more questions than answers as the final credits roll.

Anna: Nicole Kidman Young Sean: Cameron Bright Eleanor: Lauren Bacall

Directed by Jonathan Glazer. Written by Mile Addica, Jean-Claude Carriere and Jonathan Glazer. Rated R. (100 min)

[Home] [This Weeks Reviews] [Recent Reviews] [Review Archive] [A] [About A Boy] [Adventures of Pluto Nash] [AFTER THE WEDDING] [Against The ropes] [AI Artificial Intelligence] [Alex & Emma] [ALEX RIDER: OPERATION STORMBREAKER] [Alfie] [ALIEN AUTOPSY] [Alien vs Predator] [An American Haunting] [Anchorman] [An Inconvenient Truth] [ANTIBODIES] [An Unfinished Life] [ARTHUR AND THE INVISIBLES] [B] [Banger Sisters, the] [Batman Begins] [Beach Party at the Threshold of Hell] [Beauty Shop] [Behind Enemy Lines] [Bewitched] [Beyond the Sea] [Big Fat Liar] [Big Dreams Little Tokyo] [Big Fish] [Birth] [Black Dahlia, The] [Black Knight] [Bobby] [Boys and Girls Guide to Getting Down] [BREAKING AND ENTERING] [Break Up, The] [Bridget Jones: The Edge of Reason] [Bringing Down the House] [BRUCE ALMIGHTY] [Bubble] [BUG] [BUSINESS JOHNSON] [C] [Calendar Girls] [Captain Corelli's Mandolin] [Catch Me If You Can] [Cats & Dogs] [Catwoman] [Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle] [CHARLOTTE’S WEB] [Cheaper by the Dozen] [CHICAGO] [Christmas with the Kranks] [Coffee Date] [Cold Mountain] [Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen] [The Constant Gardner] [The Cooler] [Corky Romano] [Corpse Bride] [The Count of Monte Cristo] [The Country Bears] [Crash] [Cries From Ramah] [Curious George] [COME EARLY MORNING] [CHALK] [CRAZY LOVE] [D] [Daredevil] [Dark Blue] [Darkness Falls] [The Day After Tomorrow] [DAYWATCH] [Dead Girl,The] [Death of Captain Pilecki] [De-Lovely] [DEVIL CAME ON HORSEBACK,The] [Dickie Roberts: Former Child Star] [Die Another Day] [DIVERGENCE] [Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood] [Doctor Dolittle 2] [Down with Love] [Dreamcatcher] [The Dreamers] [Dukes of Hazzard] [E] [Elf] [Enough] [Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind] [Eulogy] [Evolution] [F] [Fateless] [Find Me Guilty] [Finding Nemo] [Finding Neverland] [Flyboys] [Freaky Friday] [Freddy vs Jason] [FULL GROWN MEN] [Funny Ha Ha] [FUR: AN IMAGINARY PORTRAIT OF DIANE ARBUS] [G] [Ghost Ship] [The Girl Next Door] [Girl With a Pearl Earring] [The Great Raid] [The Ground Truth] [The Guardian] [The Good German] [H] [Halloween: Resurrection] [Happy Feet] [Hardball] [Harry Potter & the Chamber of Secrets] [Harry Potter & the Goblet of Fire] [Harry Potter & the Prisoner of Azkaban] [Harry Potter & the Sorcerer's Stone] [HARRY POTTER AND THE ORDER OF THE PHOENIX] [Haunted Mansion, The] [Holes] [Hollywood Homicide] [Hollywoodland] [The Host] [How To Deal] [How to Lose a Guy in Ten Days] [Human Stain] [HOAX, THE] [HOW TO ROB A BANK] [I] [Infamous] [In Memory Of Me] [Invincible] [i Spy] [Ice Harvest] [Ice Princess] [Identity] [Impostor] [Inconvenient Truth, An] [In Good Company] [In the Cut] [In-Laws, The] [Intolerable Cruelty] [J] [Jeepers Creepers] [Jeepers Creepers 2] [Jersey Girl] [Jiminy Glick in La La Wood] [Jurassic Park III] [JUST LIKE THE SON] [Just Married] [JUMP] [K] [King Kong] [L] [Lassie] [The L.A. Riot Spectacular] [Last Rites] [Lake House, The] [Lara Croft: Tomb Raider] [Laws of Attraction] [Legally Blonde] [Legally Blonde 2: Red, White & Blonde] [Libertine, The] [Little Manhattan] [Lizzie McGuire Movie, The] [LOOKOUT, The] [Lost Skeleton of Cadavra, The] [LONELY HEARTS] [M] [Moulin Rouge] [MARIE ANTOINETTE] [The Majestic] [Man of the House] [March of the Penguins] [Master and Commander] [The Matador] [Matchstick Men] [Mean Girls] [Men in Black II] [Minority Report] [Miracle] [The Missing] [Monster-in-Law] [Monsters, Inc.] [Moonlight Mile] [The Mothman Prophecies] [Mr. Deeds] [Mrs. Henderson Presents] [Murder by Numbers] [Mystic River] [Miss Potter] [Music and Lyrics] [MEMORIES OF TOMORROW] [N] [The Night Listener] [The Notorious Bettie Page] [National Lampoon's Van Wilder] [National Treasure] [The New Guy] [The New World] [The Notebook] [O] [Oceans Eleven] [One Hour Photo] [Open Range] [The Others] [Over The Hedge] [OPAL DREAM] [Oceans 13] [OWL AND THE SPARROW] [P] [The Pacifier] [The Passion of the Christ] [Pearl Harbor] [PERFUME: THE STORY OF A MURDERER] [Phantom of the Opera] [The Pill] [Pirates of the Caribbean] [Planet of The Apes] [Pooh's Heffalump Movie] [Poseidon] [The Princess Diaries] [The Princess Diaries 2: Royal Engagement] [The Punisher] [PREMONITION] [Primer] [PRIDE] [PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN: AT WORLD’S END] [Q] [R] [ROCKY BALBOA] [Rat Race] [Red Dragon] [The Ring] [Rock Star] [The Rookie] [The Royal Tenenbaums] [RUGRATS GO WILD!] [Runaway Jury] [RV] [S] [SHREK THE THIRD] [Sixes and the One Eyed King] [SNOW CAKE] [SPIDER-MAN 3] [Straight Into Darkness] [T] [Trust The Man] [That Fall] [TRIPPER, THE] [TOWN THAT WAS,THE] [U] [Undead] [Under the Tuscan Sun] [The United States of Leland] [Uptown Girls] [V] [Van Helsing] [Vanity Fair] [The Village] [W] [Wannabe] [WILD HOGS] [WIZARD OF GORE] [X] [Y] [You Kill Me] [Z] [Zathura] [Top Ten] [Oscars] [2006 Oscar Watch] [2006 Nominees] [2007 Oscar watch] [Meet The Oscars] [2007 Nominees] [BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR & ACTRESS] [BEST PICTURE & BEST DIRECTOR] [Oscar Trivia] [Film Festivals] [2006 Film Festivals] [AFI  2006] [AFI FEST] [October 3 Press] [2006 Lineup] [2006 Jury Panels] [2006 MUST SEE] [LA Film Festival] [George Lucas] [Must See Festival Films!] [LA Film Festival Goes Green for a Day] [Competition Categories] [Narrative Feature Winner - Gretchen] [Last Rites] [The Beach Party at the Threshold of Hell] [The Bicycle Film Festival] [Celebrate Two-Wheeled Transportation] [Dances with Films] [Must See Festival Films] [Sixes and the One Eyed King] [2005 Film Festivals] [LA Film Festival] [Final Wrap 2005] [2007 Film Festivals] [INDEPENDENT SPIRIT AWARDS] [LOS ANGELES FILM FESTIVAL] [2007 Lineup] [May 23 Press] [Festival Map] [2007 Overview] [Champagne Spy,The] [Town That Was,The] [LAFF SPOTLIGHTS ROMANIAN FILM] [SEVERED WAYS] [BEAUTIFUL ORDINARY,THE] [BILLY THE KID] [SALTY AIR] [RAZZLE DAZZLE] [FLIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD] [French Films at LAFF] [Spirit of Independence Award] [DANCES WITH FILMS] [The Best Film Fest] [DAMAH FILM FESTIVAL] [Malibu Celebration of film] [May 2007 Press] [Coming Soon] [Studio Links] [Other Links] [Contact movie shark deblore] [WebMaster] [Industry Contact] [Straight To DVD] [Straight Into Darkness] [COME EARLY MORNING] [Trailers] [Photo Galleries] [AFI 2005] [AFI Photo Gallery 2005] [LAFF 2006] [The Movie Shark Collection] [Golden Globe Awards] [Legal]